
I finally found some time to sit down and type up some thoughts about the under-the-radar announcement by
Scott Snyder over on his own blog that, shockingly, Jonah Hex is getting a new title...or at least that how he seems to be phrasing it. Two weeks earlier,
DC had dropped the news that their latest publishing initiative will be titled "Next Level", to follow their current one called "All In". While the company itself only focused on Lobo, Batwoman, and Deathstroke getting books, it was Snyder who mentioned Hex, along with a ton of other characters and titles. He just tossed the bounty hunter's name out there with no other info, rather like what happened when Dan Didio name-dropped Hex in a WIZARD interview in early 2005.
As I wrote in Chapter 15 of my long-running Hex history project, we didn't get another peep from Didio or DC about what was coming until many months later, with
Jonah Hex (vol. 2) #1 finally hitting the stands in November 2005. I'm going to presume that, since this "Next Level" stuff is to begin this March, we won't be waiting as long this time around, but the same question faces us now as it did 21 years ago: What sort of Jonah Hex are we going to get?
Over on the
"Jonah Hex, Via Pony Express" Facebook page, my co-admin Darren Schroeder put up a poll to ask our members what they'd like to see in a new Hex title, giving folks nine possible versions of our favorite bounty hunter to choose from. Nearly all of them got at least one vote, and I personally couldn't decide which one to throw my weight behind, because each has the potential to be something good, and unless this hypothetical new series turns out to be something truly heinous, I will follow ol' Jonah wherever he goes. So instead, I'm going to go through Darren's list and tell you what I think DC could do with each version, starting with the one that got the highest votes and working my way down from there, even touching on those that got bupkis.
"Bounty-Hunting Wild West Hex": Garnering 79% of the votes, this version may seem like a no-brainer, but I put 50/50 odds on it being what we actually get, simply because standard Western titles -- even "weird" ones like an average Hex comic -- don't bring in high sales numbers, as proven by Jonah's previous two series. Even stunts like big-name artists and superhero guest-stars don't permanently move the needle, so unless the potential creative team has a very strong idea that they think will generate big sales over a long period, I doubt DC would put money behind a standard Western. That being said, both the creation of Jonah Hex and every revival has been loosely tied to a rising interest in Westerns via other media -- Spaghetti Westerns in the 1960s/70s, gritty revisionism like
Unforgiven in the 1990s, TV shows like
Deadwood in the 2000s -- so the creation of a third volume of a straight-shootin'
Jonah Hex could be tied to the current popularity of
Yellowstone and all its spinoffs. If this is the route DC is taking, I bet it'd be more of a limited series than a monthly title (like how they did
Jonah's Vertigo run), with it maybe getting extended if the numbers really show up this time.
"Civil War Hex": This was an intriguing notion Darren tossed out there, and about 5% of the voters agreed. With the current state of things all around us, the right writer could deliver one helluva message along with filling in a long-standing gap in Hex history. Jonah's pre-War life (i.e. the couple of years prior to 1861) has barely been touched, and while
I've written my own speculations as to how he ended up in the Confederacy, I'd love to see someone else tackle it, giving us a canonical reason as to how and why Jonah was swayed to fight for a cause he didn't believe in.
"Post-Apocalypse Hex": This version also netted 5% of the vote. I've said my piece many a time regarding HEX, both
in fanfiction and
in a historical context, so I'll quickly sum up my feelings by saying that the idea is good but the execution is terrible. That means it has the potential be turned into something great in the right hands. This could be done within its original 2050 setting -- presumably moved to an alternate DC future -- or a complete rehaul where Jonah gets dropped even further ahead in time, thereby avoiding the conundrum we're in now (i.e. we are rapidly catching up to a future that will not happen). There's even a third possibility, wherein the events of HEX get revised to fit within the framework of
Batman Beyond, allowing Hex to piggyback on what is still rather popular iteration of the Dark Knight instead of making one from scratch like Michael Fleisher originally did.
"Time Travel Hex": Yet another 5% vote, and one that I think is strongest possibility of what we're getting. Remember, over in the JLU title, Hex is still bouncing around with "Legend" and some other time-displaced heroes, and since we still don't know who
she or
he is yet, it could be that a new Jonah Hex series contributes to wrapping up that storyline. There's also the fact that this setup is essentially the same as
Legends of Tomorrow -- where Hex was a semi-regular -- plus there's the whole idea that
the Hex we're seeing is a "quantum ghost" who doesn't actually need to go back to the Old West, so yeah, a Jonah Hex title where he's constantly bopping around time seems the most likely scenario at the moment.
"Brand-New Reimagined Hex": Our final 5% vote is possible, but the potential of it backfiring is high. That's not to say he hasn't been reimagined before, as the "Future Hex", "Vertigo Hex" and "New 52" eras technically fall into that category. However, in the first and third examples, the same team who'd been writing him for years stuck with him, lending a sense of continuity, and in the second example, Joe Lansdale actually misremembered how Jonah Hex was originally presented in the 1970s, so while things went a little off-book, he somehow managed to portray Hex himself in the same manner he'd always been presented, so his "new take" was actually the same old one. And that's what is key to any new Hex title, be it a reimagined version or "back to basics" like Justin Gray & Jimmy Palmiotti did for their run: If Jonah's heart isn't there, the whole thing falls apart. I have no issues with taking him out of the Confederate uniform so long as they don't turn him into a Yankee, and I wouldn't necessarily have a problem with them changing how Jonah gets his scar so long as his surliness and ironclad personal morality remains intact. If the heart of the character is there, Jonah should be able to weather any changes. This is why I enjoy parts of
the 2010 movie despite it being an overall mess (Josh Brolin fully embraced Jonah's heart, no question), but I'm still royally pissed about
Justice League: Warworld (that man had Hex's name and face, but otherwise, he's literally a heartless bastard, and
I had to write a fic about it just to make myself feel marginally better). To sum up, if they reimagine Jonah Hex, they'd better not lose what's made the character last nearly 55 years.
"Modern-Day Hex": With only 1% of the vote, this is the last version that anyone put any support behind, and like "Time Travel Hex", I put good odds on this being where they might go, partially due again to what's happening in JLU. This "quantum ghost" of Hex has nowhere to go -- the Hex of the past is still in the past, this one merely represents a split-second of the bounty hunter's life -- so if he doesn't go bopping around the timestream and he doesn't "die", then he's stuck in the present. J&J explored the notion of Jonah dealing with the modern DCU midway through
All Star Western (vol. 3), and
I've dabbled in this area myself because I like watching the old man react to the everyday bullshit the average DCU citizen has to deal with. Pitting Jonah against a "New West" -- perhaps with his many-times-great-granddaughter Jinny Hex in tow -- would be great fun, so here's hoping.
"Alt-Universe Hex": We're down to the 0% votes, but despite there being no apparent demand for these versions, we're gonna discuss them anyways, starting with one that's rather similar to "reimagining". For this, however, I reckon it'd be something akin to Elseworlds or the new Absolute line, wherein you can REALLY go off-book. We've kinda gone down this path before, with the aforementioned
Warworld, Amalgam's
Generation Hex, and even the Tangent line had a Hex in it. Overlaying the general beats of Jonah's life over a totally new concept could be very interesting, as seen by the Elseworlds idea suggested by my pal Henry Joseph Feakes for
my pretend HEX solicits: Feakes turned the bounty hunter into a scarred Vietnam vet in the 1970s, and while we only jotted up a paragraph, it's something I'd still love to see fleshed out into an entire story. So yeah, depending on the idea, an Elseworlds/Absolute Hex would be a welcome sight.
"Supermodel Hex": I'm sure Darren tossed this out there as a gag, but since her existence was noted in the recently-published New History of the DC Universe -- her first mention in over 26 years -- the possibility of it is open! If she did come back, I would demand an explanation of what her deal is, though. And bring back her creator, Karl Kesel, while you're at it.
"Space Traveler Hex": This one is funny, because I've run across mentions of HEX that describe it as a space adventure, so there's some folks who already think ol' Jonah has gone to space! In truth, the only spacebound Hex incident I can think of was in
Justice League Action, and admittedly that was fun, so I wouldn't be against the ol' buzzard doing it in the comics. Once again, this is a good possible destination for the "quantum ghost" version of Hex in JLU, and the notion of our timelost cowboy riding off into the final frontier is full of potential. At the very least, we could see Jonah Hex butt heads with Lobo in the ultimate bounty-hunting faceoff, and how can you say no to that?
So yeah, no matter what form this potential new Jonah Hex series takes, I'll be there for it, full of hope that they do justice to his very long history. I also REALLY need to get
my Hex history project into print ASAP, so excuse me while I go back to editing!